Discussion:
Videogames deserve to be studied like Economies
(too old to reply)
s***@gmail.com
2016-04-29 18:16:14 UTC
Permalink
It is ironic, or paradoxic, that all these videogames are centered on economic systems incorporating models for which they are the model, but irregardless a model of the economies they emulate takes a very different form to make _economic_ _sense_ of the videogame. This can be understood as programmers (or designers) emulating in a computer very basic and **mechanical** phenomena (or events) we can call economic in nature, for which not all assumptions are immediately evident, and yet the models work for the game. The form of this analytical discipline is similar to the analysis of historical economies, or History of the Economy. Banks do not need to exist, in Reality terms and in videogame reality, for money to function as a measure of value to be used for transactions, for example, so we can ask, what are the mechanics of money in such or such historical economy? In real terms for a particular example we might describe the gold standard as the source of value for money and the real life mechanics of acquiring a stock of gold and the efforts (political, military...) to maintain it, as well as its distribution mechanics, conversion into coinage, etc. All these mechanics were necessary for some monied economies to work, not for others, but we are in fact interested in how things actually worked and explaining it, as well as explaining why some economies stopped working and how they were trasformed, etc. So for videogame economies we can also observe they are based on money, or some named measure of value, and then describe how such economic entity works and achieves its purpose and ontological status, even when, or precisely because, for the programmer/designer the videogame money is but a numerical variable that is incremented by these processes and decremented by these other processes, sometimes in very design-standard (genre) ways, and does not have to go further into describing its properties, verifying incrementing/decrementing processes are consistent or sensible, worry about its physical distribution (though in programming terms this problem has an equivalent in the programming problem of propagation of variable values), or otherwise make a **credible** or **real** form of money satisfying real money properties to satisfy the game function. Games do not have to create a monetary system to have their money work, in game terms, or they do create one _implictly_. It is this intrepretation what separates the product created by programmers from the objective product they created, actually giving to the discipline two ontological entities to be described, analyzed and explained, both in themselves and in relation to currently known working economic principles. So a videogame economy can be described in terms of how and to what extent it was programmed or designed as an economy, and then in terms of how it works as an economy in the game itself. This is, furthermore, a condition in practical terms to differentiate **toy models** from **real life models** from theoretical models and even to discern _games_ from serious _models_, (which may not be possible for all of us!), and extract value from them.

Danilo J Bonsignore
s***@gmail.com
2016-04-29 18:23:15 UTC
Permalink
And again, I was very inspire writing this when... pressure mouting, this time it was a Chinese boy screaming simultaneousely real-time criticisms on my use of phrase conjuctive phrases... and it was only a draft! So... one paragraph did stop in So and lost the idea. Very unsettling. May take a while before I can link other _drafted_ paragraphs, but you ought to get the idea from here on.

What about stating the implicit assumptions made to have Majesty be a real life model? I like the Thieves Guild extortion idea, and how well to do neighborhoods get unused and separated by foul rat breeding slums keeping busy all the minor heroes before the best of them can reach the Library... For instance. _Reminds_ me of NYC... See how every newbie idiot coming out of the Wizard s Guild (avg neighborhood/building) gets killed before achieving anything? Calculate conditions for income balances for n markets... I bet the programmers did not do it.

Danilo J Bonsignore.
s***@gmail.com
2016-11-28 19:50:30 UTC
Permalink
Oh, guess what? the lap this was written on was stolen from me along notes and scenarios. And police completely uncaring, even the precinct closed... and I got banned from the nycgov and the place I was robbed in in Facebook. Damned beans can...

So, what is the nature of error in fake economic models in videogames? And if the game performs better than Reality, where is the difference?

Danilo J Bonsignore

Loading...